The Neutral State: Myth or Reality?

Document Type : Article

Authors

1 Ph.D. Student in Public Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Professor in International Law and Human Rights, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran

3 Assistant Professor in Political Philosophy, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract
Liberal neutrality, considered the dominant theory in contemporary political philosophy and the central idea of the modern state, has been accompanied in practice by many issues. Its existence is also in doubt; however, the abandonment of neutrality could lead to the emergence of a totalitarian state. In this paper, based on conceptual analysis and a critical approach, reasons for the theoretical and practical impossibility of a neutral state are examined. The discussion addresses the self-contradictory nature of neutrality and its inability to justify itself impartially, its reliance on a form of atomistic individualism, its neglect of the contextual nature of values, its pursuit of cultural uniformity in non-liberal societies, the lack of free and independent will necessary for autonomy among citizens, the failures of the cultural market to provide a sufficiently wide range of options for citizens' choices, as well as the crises arising from the neutral state that envisions no ultimate purpose for human beings. This absence can strip citizens of any form of concern for virtues in the public sphere, while the neutral state plays a passive role in the flourishing of human capabilities and disregards citizens' social responsibilities as well as the necessary interventions of the state. According to the findings of this research, determining the scope of neutrality and partiality is significant, and by the distinction between the concepts of neutrality and impartiality, what is desirable and achievable is limited neutrality or impartiality. The possibility and justification of reconciliation between limited neutrality and a certain level of moral perfectionism is the subject of this paper.

Keywords

Subjects

 English
A) Books
1.     Ackerman, B. (1980). Social Justice in the Liberal State. New Haven: Yale University Press.
2.     Beckman, L. (2001). The Liberal State and the Politics of Virtue. New Jersey: Routledge.
3.     Bell, D. (1993). Communitarianism and its Critics. UK: Oxford University Press.
4.     Dworkin, R. (1985). A Matter of Principle. US: Harvard University Press.
5.     Franken, L. (2016). Liberal Neutrality and State Support for Religion. Switzerland: Springer.
6.     Green, T. H. (1986). On the Different Senses of ‘Freedom’ as Applied to the Will and the Moral Progress of Man. in Green’s Lectures on the Principles of Political Obligation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
7.     Haksar, V. (1979). Equality, Liberty and Perfectionism. UK: Oxford University Press.
8.     Hayek, F. (1960). The Constitution of Liberty. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
9.     Hurka, T. (1993). Perfectionism. UK: Oxford University Press.
10.  Jones, P. (2018). The Ideal of the Neutral State. in Liberal Neutrality. New York: Routledge.
11. Kolakowski, L. (1975). Neutrality and Academic Values. in Neutrality and Impartiality. London: Cambridge University Press.
12.  Kymlicka, W. (1990). Contemporary Political Philosophy. UK: Oxford University Press.
13. Kymlicka, W. (1994). Individual and Community Rights. in Group Rights. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
14. Kymlicka, W. (1998). Liberal Egalitarianism and Civic Republicanism: Friend or Enemies?. UK: Oxford University Press.
15.  Larmore, C. (1987). Patterns of Moral Complexity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
16. Macedo, S. (1990). Liberal Virtues: Citizenship, Virtue, and Community in Liberal Constitutionalism. UK: Oxford University Press.
17. MacIntyre, A. (1981). After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
18. MacIntyre, A. (1988). Whose Justice? Which Rationality?. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
19.  MacKinnon, C. (1989). Toward a Feminist Theory of the State. US: Harvard University Press.
20. Montefiore, A. (1975). Neutrality and Impartiality: The University and Political Commitment. London: Cambridge University Press.
21. O'connor, B. (2013). Adorno. New York: Routledge.
22. Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice. US: Harvard University Press.
23. Rawls, J. (1999). Collected Papers. US: Harvard University Press.
24. Rawls, J. (1993). Political Liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press.
25. Raz, J. (1986). The Morality of Freedom. UK: Oxford University Press.
26. Sandel, M. (1982). Liberalism and the Limits of Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
27. Sher, G. (1997). Beyond Neutrality: Perfectionism and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
28. Skinner, Q. (2003). States and Freedom of Citizens. in States and Citizens (History, Theory, Prospects). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29. Taylor, C. (1979). Hegel and Modern Society. Cambridge University Press.
30. Taylor, C. (1985). Philosophy and the Human Sciences: Philosophical Papers. Vol. 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
31. Taylor, C. (1994). Philosophy in an Age of Pluralism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32. Taylor, C. (1989). Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
33. Waldron, J. (1993). Liberal rights. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
34. Wall, S. (1998). Liberalism, Perfectionism and Restraint. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35. Young, I. M. (1990). Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
 
B) Articles
36. Arneson, R. (2003). Liberal Neutrality on the Good: An Autopsy. in Perfectionism and Neutrality: Essays in Liberal Theory. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 191-218.
37. Caney, S. (1991). Consequentialist Defenses of Liberal Neutrality. The Philosophical Quarterly, 41 (165), 457-477.
38. Frankfurt, H. (1971). Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person. Journal of Philosophy, 68 (1), 5-20.
39. Gardbaum, S. (1991). Why the Liberal State Can Promote Moral Ideals After All?. Harvard Law Review, 104 (6), 1350-1371.
40. Hurka, T. (1998). Review of “Beyond Neutrality: Perfectionism and Politics”. Ethics, 109 (1), 187-190.
41. Iwasa, N. (2010). The Impossibility of Political Neutrality. Croatian Journal of Philosophy, 10 (29), 147-155.
42. MacIntyre, A. (1983). Moral Rationality, Tradition and Aristotle: A Reply to Onora O'Neill, Raimond Gaita and Stephen R. L. Clark. Inquiry, 26 (4), 447-466.
43.  Mang, F. Chan, J. (2022). Perfectionism. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. 1-22.
44. Nagel, T. (1973). Rawls on Justice. The Philosophical Review, 82 (2), 220-234.
45. Rawls, J. (1985). Justice as Fairness: Political not Metaphysical. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 14 (3), 223-251.
46. Tütüncü, K. (2013). Liberalism, Neutrality and the Politics of Virtue. SEER Journal for Labour and Social Affairs in Eastern Europe, 16 (1), 41-45.
47. Venezia, J. L. (2009). Political Liberalism and the Characterization of the Moral Virtues. Enrahonar, 43, 131-152.
48. Waldron, J. (1989). Autonomy and Perfectionism in Raz’s Morality of Freedom. Southern California Law Review, 62, 1097-1152.
49. Wall, S. (2021). Perfectionism in Moral and Political Philosophy. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy; available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/perfectionism-moral/
 
C) Theses
50. Cordell, S. (2010). Virtue Ethics in the Contemporary Social and Political Realm. PhD Thesis of Philosophy. University of Sheffield.
51. Franz, F.L., (2015). Beyond Public Reason Liberalism: Moderate Perfectionism. PhD Thesis of Politics. University of Oxford.
 
References In Persian:
Berlin, I. (2014). Four Essays on Liberty. Mohammad Ali Movahhed (trans.). Tehran: Kharazmi (In Persian).
Dewey, J. (2023). Liberalism and Social Action. Reza Yaghoubi (trans.). Tehran: Kargadan (In Persian).
Fukuyama, F. (2022). Liberalism and its Discontents. Rahman Ghahremanpour (trans.). Tehran: Rozaneh (In Persian).
Gray, J. (2024). Liberalism. Seyyed Alireza Hosseini Beheshti (trans.). Tehran: Rozaneh (In Persian).
Hampton, J. (2007). Political Philosophy. Khashayar Deyhimi (trans.). Tehran: Tarh Now (In Persian).
Hosseini Beheshti, S. A. (2016). Theoretical Foundations of Politics in Multicultural Societies. Tehran: Nahid (In Persian).
Kymlicka, W. (2018). Contemporary Political Philosophy: An Introduction. Meysam Badamchi & Mohammad Mobasheri, (trans.). Tehran: Negah Moaser (In Persian).
Malekian, M. (2000). MacIntyre’s Moral and Political Opinions. Tehran: Boqee (In Persian).
Mendus, S. (2016). Impartiality in Moral and Political Philosophy. Fatemeh Sadat Hosseini (trans.). Tehran: taha (In Persian).
Nagel, T. (2021). Equality and Partiality. Javad Heydari (trans.). Tehran: Nashr Now (In Persian).
Nussbaum, M. (2022). The Quality of Life. Hasan Fesharaki (trans.). Tehran: Shirazeh. (In Persian)
Parvin, P., Chambers, C.(2023). Political Philosophy: A Complete Introduction. Javad Heydari, (trans.). Tehran: Soroush Molana (In Persian).
Rajaei, F,(2023). Virtuous Life in Secular Age. Tehran: Agah (In Persian).
Sandel, M, (2019). Public Philosophy: Essays on Morality in Politics. Afshin Khakbaz (trans.). Tehran: Nashr Now (In Persian).
Sayers, S, (2020). Karl Marx. Saleh Najafi (trans.). Tehran: Lega (In Persian).
Solomon, D, (2020). Alasdair MacIntyre. Kaveh Behbahani (trans.). Tehran: Lega (In Persian).
Taylor, C, (2023). The Causes of the Crisis: Atomism. in Virtuous Life in Secular Age. Tehran: Agah (In Persian).
Taylor, C,. & Maclure, J, (2020). Secularism and Freedom of Conscience. Mahdi Hosseini (trans.). Tehran: Rouzbahan (In Persian).
Volume 56, Issue 2 - Serial Number 46
Summer 2026
Spring 2026
Pages 875-904

  • Receive Date 17 February 2025
  • Revise Date 09 April 2025
  • Accept Date 05 May 2025