Public Law Studies Quarterly

Evaluating UN Practice in the Settlement of Identity-Based Territorial Conflicts with a View on the Cyprus, Karabakh and Kosovo Cases

Document Type : Article

Authors

Sattar Azizi 1
Mousa Karami 2

1 Prof., Department of Law, Faculty of Humanities, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran

2 Ph. D. Candidate in Public International Law, Faculty of Law, University of Qom, Qom, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22059/jplsq.2022.342025.3070
Abstract
The conflicts between minority groups and the central government are considered to be one of the current threats to international peace and security. Employing the descriptive-analytical method and studying three cases of Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, Nagorno-Karabakh and Kosovo, this paper seeks to analyze the performance of UN in settling the identity-based territorial conflicts. The authors believe that the reason behind the failure of UN in settlement of Cyprus and Karabakh crises is that the Security Council has always supported the rights of Cyprus and Azerbaijan to maintain their territorial integrity without mentioning the possibility of the realization of right to remedial secession. In fact, the Council has always given an unconditional guarantee to central governments and thereby has lost its pressure tool on these states to grant appropriate privileges to secessionist groups in order to persuade them to abandon their secessionist demands. On the contrary, through implicit recognition of remedial secession as the last resort and after the deadlock of negotiations, this organization has had a relatively successful performance in Kosovo problem and impeded the continuation of an endless crisis. It appears that the report-card of this Organization in this regard is neither black nor white; it is grey and this leaves us in a world of fears and hopes.

Keywords

UN
Security Council
identity-based conflicts
remedial secession
territorial integrity
Subjects

  1. English

    1. A) Books
    2. Dietzel, I. (2014). The Ecology of Coexistence and Conflict in Cyprus: Exploring the Religion, Nature, and Culture of a Mediterranean Island. Boston/Berlin/Munich: Walter de Gruyter, Inc.
    3. Herscher, A. (2010). Violence Taking Place: The Architecture of the Kosovo Conflict. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
    4. Krüger, Heiko (2010). The Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict: A Legal Analysis, Berlin/Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.
    5. Mello, Patrick A. (2014). Democratic Participation in Armed Conflict Military Involvement in Kosovo, Afghanistan, and Iraq. Hampshire: Palgrave McMillan.
    6. Lu, J. (2018). On State Secession from International Law Perspectives, Cham: Springer.
    7. Nasic, H. (2007). Minority Rights Instruments and Mechanisms: Minority Protection along the Conflict Continuum. Bolzan: European Academy.
    8. Visoka, G. (2017). Shaping Peace in Kosovo: The Politics of Peacebuilding and Statehood. Hampshire: Palgrave McMillan.

     

    1. B) Articles
    2. Akani, E. C. (2020). The United Nations (UN) and Human Rights: Challenges and Prospects.African Journal of Political Science and International Relations, 14(2), 91-102.
    3. Anastasiou, H. (2011). A Brief Historical Overview of the Cyprus Problem.in: Harry Anastassiou, The Broken Olive Branch: Nationalism, Ethnic Conflict, and the Quest for Peace in Cyprus (Volume I). New York: Syracuse University Press, pp. 75-108.
    4. de Wall, T. (2021). The Nagorny Karabakh Conflict in Its Fourth Decade. CEPS Working Document No. 2021-02; available at: https://www.ceps.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/WD2021-02_The-Nagorny-Karabakh-Conflict-in-its-Fourth-Decade.pdf
    5. Ker-Lindsay, J., & Richmond, O. P. (2001). Introduction: Testing the United Nations Organization: The Case of Cyprus. in: Oliver P. Richmond and James Ker-Lindsay (eds.). The Work of the UN in Cyprus: Promoting Peace and Development, Hampshire: Palgrave McMillan, pp. xiv-xxiii.
    6. Khalid, I. (2008). Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict. Journal of Political Studies, 14, 25-44.
    7. Kymlicka, W. (2000). Federalism and Secession: At Home and Abroad", Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence, 13(2), pp. 207-224.
    8. Kymlicka, W. (2008). Internationalization of Minority Rights. International Journal of Constitutional Law, 6(1), 1–32.
    9. Loizides, Neophytos and McGarry, J. (2019). The 2002-04 Annan Plan in Cyprus: An Attempted UN-Mediated Constitutional Transition. Forum of Federations, Occasional Paper Series Number 27; Available at: https://constitutionnet.org/sites/default /files/2019-06/Cyprus_27.pdf
    10. Lulić, Mira and Muhvić, Davor (2009). International Law and Cyprus Problem. in: Ivana Barković and Mira Lulić (eds.), Contemporary Legal and Economic Issues II, Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek Faculty of Law Osijek, Croatia, 65-96.
    11. Mederios, M. (2021). Beyond the Label: Exploring the Role of Ethnicity in the Kosovo Conflict", Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism, 21(3), 260-275.
    12. Melenao, I.(2019). "A Historical Account of the Cyprus Problem and the Annan Plan: A Unique Opportunity or an Unwelcome Solution?", Akropolis, 3(3), 29-61.
    13. Michael, S. Michalis (2007). The Cyprus Talks: A Critical Appraisal. Journal of Peace Research, 44(5), 587-604.
    14. Milano, E. (2003). Security Council Action in the Balkans: Reviewing the Legality of Kosovo's Territorial Status. European Journal of International Law, 14(5), 999-1022.
    15. Rogel, C. (2003). Kosovo: Where It All Began. International Journal of Politics, Culture and Society, 17(1), 167-182.
    16. Schwartz, Matthew (2014). "Challenges at the Nexus of Security and Promotion and Protection of Human Rights", paper presented in International Conference on Security and Human Rights in the Arab Region, 5-6 November 2014, Ritz Carlton Hotel, Doha, Qatar.
    17. Van den Driest, S. F. (2015). From Kosovo to Crimea and Beyond: On Territorial Integrity, Unilateral Secession and Legal Neutrality in International Law. International Journal on Minority and Group Rights, 22 (4), 467-485.
    18. Weller, M. (2008). Kosovo Final Status. International Affairs, 84(6), 1223-1243.
    19. Wippman, D. (2001). Kosovo and the Limits of International Law. Fordham International Law Journal, 25(1), pp. 129-150.

     

    1. C) Dissertations
    2. Biru Kersmo, T. (2021). The Nexus between Ethnic Politics and Ethnic Conflicts: The Case of Ethiopia, MA Dissertation in Peace, Conflict and Diplomacy, London, London Metropolitan University.
    3. Geci, S. (2008). Kosovo’s Final Status Negotiation Process:
      A Way Out or Cul-de Sac      , MA Dissertation in Contemporary Diplomacy, Faculty of Arts, University of Malta.

     

    1. D) Reports
    2. Srinivasan, S. (2006). Minority Rights, Early Warning and Conflict Prevention: Lessons from Darfur (Report), Minority Rights Group International (MRGI). Available at: www.minorityrights.org.
    3. International Crisis Group (2007). Kosovo: No Good Alternatives to the Ahtisari Plan, Europe Report N°182; available at: https://www.refworld.org/pdfid/464969da2.pdf

     

    1. E) Resolutions
    2. UNGA (1 November 1974). Resolution 3212 (XXIX), A/RES/32/12 (1974).
    3. UNSC (4 March 1964). Resolution 186 (1964), S/5575 (1964).
    4. UNSC (13 December 1974). Resolution 365 (1974), S/RES/365 (1974).
    5. UNSC (12 March 1975). Resolution 367 (1975), S/RES/365 (1975).
    6. UNSC (18 November 1983). Resolution 541 (1983), S/RES/541 (1983).
    7. UNSC (11 May 1984). Resolution 550 (1984), S/RES/550 (1984).
    8. UNSC (30 April 1993). Resolution 822 (1993), S/RES/822 (1993).
    9. UNSC (29 July 1993). Resolution 853 (1993), S/RES/853 (1993).
    10. UNSC (14 October 1993). Resolution 874 (1993), S/RES/874 (1993).
    11. UNSC (12 November 1993). Resolution 884 (1993), S/RES/884 (1993).
    12. UNSC (31 March 1998). Resolution 1160 (1998), S/RES/1160 (1998).
    13. UNSC (23 September 1998). Resolution 1199 (1998), S/RES/1199 (1998).
    14. UNSC (24 October 1998). Resolution 1203 (1998), S/RES/1203 (1998).
    15. UNSC (14 May 1999). Resolution 1239 (1999), S/RES/1239 (1999).
    16. UNSC (10 June 1999). Resolution 1244 (1999), S/RES/1244 (1999).
    17. UNSC (10 September 2001). Resolution 1367 (2001). S/RES/1367 (2001).

     

    References in Persian:

    1. A) Books
    2. Abdollahi, M., & Abdollahi, J. (2014). Cultural Genocide; Background, Foundations, Capability to be Criminalized and Examples. Tehran: Majd Publication (In Persian).
    3. Azimi, M. (2013). Minorities in International: History, Treaties, Limits and Protections. Tehran: Pardis-e-Danesh (In Persian).
    4. Azizi, S. (2015). Protection of Minorities in International Law, 2nd edition, Tehran: Shahr-e-Danesh Publication (In Persian).
    5. Azizi, Sattar (2021). Right to Self-Determination in the Mirror of International Law (First Volume: External Self-Determination). 1st published, Hamedan, Bu-Ali Sina University Publishing (In Persian).
    6. Cordell, K., & Wolff, S. (2014). Ethnic Conflicts. Translated by: Abdollah Ramezanzadeh, Tehran: Farhangshenasi and Mizan Publication (In Persian).
    7. Falsafi, H. (2004). International Law of Treaties. 2nd edition, Tehran: Nashr-e-Nou Publication (In Persian).
    8. Javanshir Gharabaghi, M. J.(2002). The History of Karabakh. Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs Publishing Center (In Persian).
    9. Kymlicka, W. (2019). Multicultural Citizenship; A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights. 2nd edition, Tehran: Shirazeh (In Persian).
    10. UN (2005). Basic Facts About United Nations, Translated by: Ali Isari Kasmaie, Tehran: Isari Publication (In Persian).
    11. Zol’ein, P. (2009). The Foundations of Public International Law, 6th edition, Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs Publishing Center (In Persian).

     

    1. B) Articles
    2. Aghamohammadi, Ebrahim and Aghmirlou, Ali (2016). Studying the Karabakh Conflict from the Perspective of Nations’ Right to Self-Determination. Historical Studies of War, 1(2), 1-18 (In Persian).

    12, Ardalan, A. (2015). Protection of Minorities in International Instruments and Regime. in: As’ad Ardalan, Rights of Nations, Sanandaj: College Publication, 27-67 (In Persian).

    1. Ashrafi, D. (2014). A New Interpretation of International Peace and Security and Its Impact on the Concept of Sovereignty. Public Law Research, 15(42), 83-109 (In Persian).
    2. Azizi, S. (2008). Kosovo Independence: Studying the Legitimacy of Unilateral Secession in International Law., International Law Review, 38, 11-45 (In Persian).
    3. Azizi, S. (2010). Russia’s Legal Position and Arguments in the Recognition of Abkhazia and South Ossetia Republics and Non-Recognition of Kosovo. International Law Review, 27(42), 65-87 (In Persian).
    4. Beygzadeh, E. (2008). In the Quest of Sustainable Peace. Razavi’s University Theology and Law (Legal Doctrines), 8(11), 3-36 (In Persian).
    5. Fazaeli, Mostafa (2016). “Military Intervention in Yemen from the Perspective of International Law”, Public Law Studies Quarterly, 46(1), 41-70 (In Persian).
    6. Kardooni, N., Ziaie Bigdeli, M., Nikpay, A., & Zamani, S. G. (2018). Modern War and the Conflicts of Multicultural Societies in International Law. Political and International Researches, 9(35), 303-326 (In Persian).
    7. Menouie, F., Shams Borhan, I., & Mousazadeh, E. (2022). “Administrative and Ethnic Federalism; A Comparative Study of Iraqi and German Federal Systems”, Public Law Studies Quarterly, 52(2), 641-660 (In Persian).
    8. Parsamehr, M., & Mirmousavi, S. A.(2020). Settlement of Minority Issue in the Light of the Right to Self-Determination’s Modern Approach. Public Law Studies Quarterly, 50(1), 373-399 (In Persian).
    9. Teson, F. (2016). nternational Law Theory of Kant. Translated by: Babak Vosoughizadeh, in: Different Authors (Supervised by: Mahmoud Bagheri), Philosophical Schools of International Law, 2nd edition, Tehran: Mizan Publication, 145-202 (In Persian).

     

    1. C) Theses and Dissertations
    2. Khaghani, M. (2021). Success or Failure of UN Security Council in the Settlement of Territorial Conflicts: With a View on Karabakh Conflict. MA Dissertation in International Law (Supervisor: Ali Mohammad Mokarrami), Saveh, Razavieh High Education Center of Saveh (In Persian).
    3. Ja’fari, Sajjad (2019). Assessing the Performance of UN and The Organization of Security and Cooperation as to the Karabakh Conflict. MA Dissertation in Diplomacy and International Organizations (Supervisor: Mohammd Hasan Sheykh-ol-Eslami), Tehran, Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ Faculty of International Relations (In Persian).
    4. Ghotbi, A. (September 2017). Statehood of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus form the Perspective of International Law, MA Dissertation in International Law (Supervisor: Sattar Azizi), Tehran, Tarbiyat-e-Modarres’ Faculty of Law (In Persian).
    5. Soleymani, A. (September 2020). Security Challenges of Turkey and NATO Relations in the Reign of Justice and Development Party (2001-2019). MA Dissertation in Political Science (Supervisor: Seyed Javad Salehi), Shiraz, Shiraz University’s Faculty of Law and Political Science (In Persian).
Public Law Studies Quarterly
Volume 53, Issue 4
Winter 2024
Winter 2024
Pages 1695-1719

  • Receive Date 22 April 2022
  • Revise Date 12 July 2022
  • Accept Date 24 October 2022

Home

Journal Process Ethics

Peer Review Process

Submission

Indexing and Abstracting

Contact Us